Skip to main content

Breaks

As spring break looms I often think about what are graduate student rights when it comes to breaks and vacation. My contract guarantees me with no time off from my mandated 20hrs/week of research which is already somewhat of a joke. I have heard horror stories of students being expected to work through Christmas and major holidays due to an advisor not allowing them to take time off and I wonder, why aren't graduate students treated like real employees in addition to students? Surely this idea isn't novel but there should be university policy guaranteeing graduate students with rights.

This ties into my continued worries of the lack of breaks in academia but the expectation that graduate school is not a typical job seems fraught with flaws. You should not be expected to postpone all life, financial, and mental health goals in order to get a PhD. Academia cannot be this toxic to its lowest denominator. I wish my lab had a given policy or expectation of allowable vacation days throughout the year, like a job. I understand that sometimes things come up or experiments must run but I feel that is not too different from any job.  I know individuals appreciate the freedom that comes with academia but with that freedom comes a double edged sword. You can work whenever you want but the premise is you are always working.

I have heard of graduate students unionizing at other schools to ensure there is fair treatment by supervisors and I have to say, this may seem fair. The main argument against it that I have seen is that the advisor/advisee relationship is very different than that of an employer/employee, but I sometimes wonder, How? Sure their success depends on my success and vice versa but how is that different from any other company? As I sit in the snow and the undergrads talk about their trips to Florida I do think it would be nice to at least know I was allowed to take time throughout the year without a constant approval system that leads you worrying if your employer thinks you are taking too much time off.

Happy Spring Break!


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Mission Statements

I chose to look at and compare the mission statements of 3 colleges/ universities close to my family; Michigan State University (MSU), Addis Ababa Institute of Technology (AAiT) and Macalester College. I was interested in how the mission of a small liberal arts college like Macalester would compare with two much larger universities and how an international setting would alter the stated mission.

All three missions are quoted below with links to finding them. Examining each mission statement I was struck by how the different emphases related back to the school's identity. AAIT emphasizes the importance of "technology transfer" which I think is vital to helping educate the public of Ethiopia. MSU, as a contrast, emphasizes research and improving quality of life around the world and Macalester, as an internationally oriented small liberal arts school, really reflects this in their stated mission. I am interested in the contrasting lengths and vagueness that comes with establ…

Research Misconduct

As a PhD student and someone who's entire life is focused around research right now, I am often frustrated by the continuous analysis and iterating that comes from producing quality work. I know though that I want my work to mean something and that I need to do the due diligence whether it be in statistics, experiments, or quality assurance/ quality control and as frustrating as it is sometimes, I do enjoy it. I also continually try to remind myself that falsification, unethical research and practices hurt more than me if I were to engage in it. It hurts my professor, my family, my field and the societies relationship with science and research.

This week, looking at the Office of Research Integrity cases that come up I chose to focus on a recent case of Dr. Li Wang. She is being reported for "research misconduct by recklessly including false data" in grant applications. She did withdraw 3 of them and has been remorseful but still I wonder if her 'punishment''…

Student Loans

Student loans make sense to me to a degree and that degree really only applies to my parents generation. When you were taking out a loan that you could realistically repay in a summer or two of full time work. I do moderately agree with the idea that you should have some stake in your education but , and this is where I get liberal, as an 18 year old you should not be allowed to make a decision that will essentially having you buy a house without the house. I think there is (was? I'm not sure if it has past now) an issue with parents not transparently conveying to their kids the cost of higher ed. I do know parents who were much more transparent with their children about it but that was not the majority.

I get that as parents you want to give your child the world and we are told growing up to apply to the best school you can but I think this is really misleading and honestly detrimental. I wish that in the US you could go to the best school you were qualified for regardless of cos…
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.